catalogs logo logo

Most Popular Pizza Toppings

By Catalogs Editorial Staff

Pizza close upContributed by Info Guru Lindsay Shugerman

Pizza. It’s our go-to food as a country. Working late? Order in pizza. Movie night? Pizza is probably on the menu. Pizza shows up at date nights, busy family nights and grab-something-on-the-way-home nights.

But what do we want to eat on all those slices of cheesy, sauced deliciousness? Of course, some of use are leading the way to new and creative tastes with things like kale and quinoa pizza, cauliflower pizza and gluten-free, vegan cheese pizza. But for most Americans, the old favorites are still the most popular.

Here’s a run-down of the ten most popular pizza toppings.

Before you continue reading about the Most Popular Pizza Toppings there is a special announcement we would like to share with you. has negotiated special medicare rates for our vibrant community of seniors. If you are over the age of 60, you can head over to our Seniors Health Section which is full of information about medicare. All you need is your zip code and a few minutes of your time to potentially save 100s of dollars on your medicare bills.

Get Free Catalogs When You Sign Up

Don't wait, sign up and get Free Shipping Offers, Discount Codes and lots of Savings Now!

10. Extra cheese

cheesey pizza

If some cheese is good, a whole bunch more is even better. Or at least that’s what we say when we place orders for all those extra cheese pizzas. Mozzarella leads the way in pizza cheese choices, followed by Provolone, Cheddar, Parmigiano-Reggiano, Romano and Ricotta.

9. Pepperoni

Pepperoni pizza

Those small rounds of spicy meat are always at the top of the list for pizza toppings. Despite its Italian-sounding name, this spicy, meaty sausage is a purely American invention.

Every year, people in this country consume about 251,770,000 pounds of pepperoni, mostly on pizza. New vegetarian versions exist, too, so even non-meat eaters can now order this beloved topping.

8. Mushrooms

pizza with mushrooms

Mushrooms are one of those toppings that seems to appeal to almost everyone. Vegetarians love having such a flavorful topping, while meat eaters enjoy the way mushrooms work with sausage, hamburger or ham.

7. Black olives

Pizza with olives

The salty, tangy taste of cured black olives is a perfect match for pizza’s rich, spicy flavors. Some like their pizza olives whole, some like the sliced, and others prefer them finely chopped. But anyway they’re prepared, they’re a popular choice alone or with other toppings like roasted tomatoes, mushrooms or sausage.

6. Onions

pizza with onions

Onions on a pizza can cook quickly in the oven, or can be slow cooked until they’re sweet and soft then added to the pizza for that final burst of cooking. Either way, cooked onions have been one of the most popular choices for decades. And if current orders are a guide, they’re still earning their top ten spot.

5. Pineapple

pizza with pineapple

At first glance, pineapple doesn’t sound like a good choice as a pizza topping. After all, it’s a fruit…and fruit and pizza don’t mix! But somehow, pineapple is the one exception. This juicy fruit can stand alone, or work with peppers, olives, sausage, ham or jalapenos.

4. Crumbled sausage

Pizza with sausage

Crumbled, spicy Italian sausage is a given when it comes to the top ten pizza toppings. Unlike some meats, sausage can stand up to the intense heat of the pizza oven without drying out or turning to leather. And the spicy seasons add another layer of flavor to any pizza, whether as a single topping or part of an “everything” pizza.

3. Green pepper

Pizza with green peppers

Not only do green peppers taste delicious on pizza, they look pretty too. It doesn’t really matter which it is… people just keep selecting this veggie for their pizzas. Roasted red peppers are starting to give green peppers a run for their money, but for now, the classic greens still have it.

2. Ham

Pizza with ham

On its own, or paired with pineapple, green peppers or other toppings, ham is a pizza classic that still rates high marks from pizza fans across the country. Some people prefer the ham to be cooked under the cheese, while others like sprinkling cooked ham over the top after the pie comes out of the oven.

1. Just the way it is

Cheese pizza

According to food industry experts, the most common choice in pizza toppings is…none. A whopping 37% of pizzas ordered are plain, cheese pizzas. The classic combination of tomato sauce, olive oil, cheese and herbs on a crust is apparently the perfect version of pizza for most of us.

Popular Savings Offers

Pizza toppings can divide a room, a party or even a family! Make sure you get everyone’s favorites when it’s time to order this all-American treat.


Top Deals

See All

Recent Posts

Get Free Catalogs When You Sign Up

Don't wait, sign up and get Free Shipping Offers, Discount Codes and lots of Savings Now!


Saving Tools

Follow Us


Since 1996, has been considered the web's catalog shopping authority. Our trends experts have carefully reviewed thousands of catalogs and online stores and have featured only the most respected, distinctive, and trusted ones. From popular favorites to new discoveries, you'll shop and save with exclusive coupon codes!

Invitations for applications for insurance on are made through QuoteLab, LLC and Submission of your information constitutes permission for an agent to contact you with additional information about the cost and coverage details of health and auto insurance plans. Descriptions are for informational purposes only and subject to change. Insurance plans may not be available in all states. For a complete description, please call to determine eligibility and to request a copy of the applicable policy. is not affiliated with or endorsed by the United States government or the federal Medicare program. By using this site, you acknowledge that you have read and agree to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.